Which one do you like? Shall I invest on a cutting plotter?

avatar

Next month, I will host a workshop at a maker event in the neighboring city of Chemnitz. I have been brainstorming a craft plus tech idea. The concept is shaping up nicely. Since I am Japanese, I want to include an origami-ish element, and because we are getting close to the festive season, I think about star ornaments out of paper with a light inside.

As always, I do not suffer from a lack of ideas. The struggle comes from having too many and wondering knowing which one to choose. So I thought I would ask the DIY community and everyone on Hive for advice.


Dilemma 1 – Finding the balance between difficulty and outcome

A) Star polyhedron

I tried a few prototypes, and the small stellated dodecahedron looks the most star like and I love the way it looks. Please ignore the tape in this early experimental version 😉

C1B4B152-FFBF-428C-ABBE-5CF389AF9FBA_1_201_a.jpeg

However, if I use unit origami technique to create a stellated dodecahedron, it requires 30 units. Even when made as a paper craft version, it needs 12 pieces, and that may be a bit too advanced for small children or beginners who are not used to detailed craftwork. Maybe this is my ego talking, but if participants are making something, I want them to take home a result they love and can proudly display and enjoy.

I have an idea that adds even more fun here. I could prepare templates for triangular and square pyramids, so people can change the size of their stars depending on their skill level. Though, even the simplest version with just 6 square pyramids still requires fairly nimble fingers. This is the dilemma...

900254EF-A2C9-48BE-BFFE-A229228D6B60_1_201_a.jpeg

F8841593-AF4E-42D6-816D-A8AAF87340B2_1_105_c.jpeg

B) One-sheet star

Another idea uses a single sheet of paper. You twist and tuck the paper into a shape, creating a star. I remembered making the pentagonal box from Jun Mitani’s book “Curved Origami” a few years ago for Christmas and filling it with treats. This time, based on that pattern, I made some changes such as making the slits deeper to make it look star-like.

39D78B6C-8238-4F00-953F-A6C097EBB5E3_1_102_o.jpeg

I think everyone could finish this one with just a little help.

Which would be better? Or should I just offer both? 😁


Dilemma 2 – To buy a cutting plotter or not

A cutting plotter costs about 299 euros, which is a kind of investment for me. A friend who is a popup-card artist uses a Cricut Explore and the pieces she showed me looked so good. Considering that we expect around 60 participants for this workshop, having one would make the preparation infinitely easier, whichever star design we choose.

Cricut Explore 4 / https://cricut.com/de-de/schneidemaschinen/cricut-explore/cricut-explore-4/cricut-explore-4/2011073.html

Since it counts as a business expense for my designer/artist work and the workshop payment is already confirmed, maybe I should go for it. If you like this post, please upvote to cheer me on 😁


Even though there are decisions to be made, I really enjoy preparing projects like this. I adore polyhedral designs. What do you think? Which idea should I choose? What about the cutting plotter?

Once the design is finalized, I plan to release the data as open source so that people who cannot attend the workshop can still enjoy star-making at home for the holidays.


Even though I have some things to figure out, I truly love this kind of design work and I am having a great time preparing for the workshop.

Which idea do you think would work best? What do you think about buying the cutting plotter?

Once the plan is finalized, I am thinking of releasing the data as open source so that even those who cannot attend the workshop can enjoy making stars at home for Christmas ☺️

⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️

来月末に、隣町のケムニッツのメイカーイベントでワークショップをすることになり、クラフト+テックなアイディアを考えています。骨子は固まっていて、私が日本人ということもあり、折り紙要素を入れて、この時期に飾れる星を紙で作って中にライトを入れる予定です。

毎度のことながら、アイディアが出なくて困るのではなく、アイディアが絞れずに困っています 💦 そこでDIYコミュニティのみなさん、Hiveのみなさんに質問してみようと思いました。


お悩み 1 - 難易度と成果物のバランス

A) 星型多面体

いくつか試作してみて、星形小12面体が最も星らしくてきれいで見た目を気に入っています。試作段階でセロテープが気になるのはご愛嬌。

C1B4B152-FFBF-428C-ABBE-5CF389AF9FBA_1_201_a.jpeg

ただ、ユニット折り紙で星形小12面体を作るとユニット数が30になり、ペーパークラフト的に作るにしても12ピースは必要で、小さい子どもやクラフトに慣れていない人にはきれいに作るのは難しそうです。私のエゴかもしれませんが、せっかく作るのだから、大満足の物を持って帰ってもらって、飾って使ってもらいたい。

このプランについてはさらにおもしろいアイデアがあって、三角錐や四角錐の型紙も用意しておいて、スキルに合わせて星形多面体の大きさを変えられるな・・・なんて。とはいえ、6面に四角錐を配置するものでも結構手先が器用な方がよく、悩ましいです。

900254EF-A2C9-48BE-BFFE-A229228D6B60_1_201_a.jpeg

F8841593-AF4E-42D6-816D-A8AAF87340B2_1_105_c.jpeg

B) 紙一枚で作る星

もう1案は、一枚の紙をくるくる折って絞って、星を作るものです。以前クリスマスに、三谷純先生の『曲線が美しい立体折り紙』に掲載されている「五角形ボックス」を作って、お菓子を入れて渡したのを思い出して、五角形ボックスのパターンをもとに切り込みを深くして星らしくしてみました。

39D78B6C-8238-4F00-953F-A6C097EBB5E3_1_102_o.jpeg

これは小さい子どもやクラフトに慣れていない人でも、ちょっとした手助けがあれば完成させられると思います。

ああ、悩ましい・・・みなさんはどっちがよいと思いますか?それともこのさい両方やっちゃいましょうか。


お悩み 2 - カッティングプロッターを買うか否か

299ユーロと少なからずお値段がするので迷っています。ポップアップカードアーティストの友人が最近Cricut Exploreというカッティングプロッターで作ったものを見て、私も欲しい!というのと、今回のワークショップの参加者見積もりが60人で準備を考えると、どちらの星を作るにしてもあると事前準備が格段に楽になりそうです。

Cricut Explore 4 / https://cricut.com/de-de/schneidemaschinen/cricut-explore/cricut-explore-4/cricut-explore-4/2011073.html

経費にできて、かつワークショップの報酬が見えているのでやっぱり買っちゃうか。買っちゃおう。よかったらこの投稿をupvoteして応援してください 😉


そんなこんなで悩みはあるものの、こういう感じの多面体デザインは大好きで、楽しく準備を進めています。みなさんはどの案がいいと思いますか?カッティングプロッターの購入についてどう思いますか?

案が固まったら、ワークショップに来れない人もクリスマスに向けて星づくりを楽しんでもらえるようにデータはオープンソースで公開しようと考えています。



0
0
0.000
5 comments
avatar

I love option B straightaway! Look forward to the open source instructions!

0
0
0.000
avatar

With 60 participants and a festive theme, I’d run the one sheet star as the main flow and have a small pro corner for the stellated version, so beginners get wins while crafty hands can flex. The Jun Mitani inspired twist looks perfect for quick success and safe for small fin;gers. On the plotter, the time you save on templating, clean edges and repeatability will pay back fast,especially if you keep using it for future workshops and product DeSign :)

0
0
0.000
avatar

The star polyhedron looks stunning and would definitely impress participants, but I agree it might be a bit complex for beginners. Maybe offering both versions could be the perfect balance. Those who love a challenge can go for the polyhedron, while others can enjoy the one-sheet star and still feel accomplished. As for the cutting plotter, I think it’s a worthy investment, especially since it’ll make prep easier and can be reused for future workshops or projects. Can’t wait to see how your final workshop turns out!

0
0
0.000
avatar

que bello! está genial!


how beautiful! It's great!

0
0
0.000