CLF - CriptoLatinFest 2025 - ValuePlan Transparency Report
As a culmination of what was a pretty big year for travelling, especially for HIVE, we attended Cripto Latin Fest in Medellín. There is a post to write about "marketing HIVE", and what I have learned over 3 events in Latin America - Talent Land Guadalajara, HIVE Hub Hotel Guatemala and Cripto Latin Fest Medellín. The evolution of the methods, the development of metrics and KPIs, and the shift in focus to retention and stickiness.
But first, as I would expect and we all should expect of anyone receiving ValuePlan funding, I need to do a report on "the money" related to Cripto Latin Fest, and unfortunately, its not a totally ideal scenario.
While all the information is clearly available on chain, I will put the pieces together to the best of my ability here in this post.
https://x.com/EcoInstant/status/1958558367900709041
Logistics
In the Guadalajara event there was value plan funding, managed by @starkerz and @eddiespino, with a tremendous report, and afterwards I did apply for and receive some additional cost recovery from guiltyparties. After that event we returned home for a bit before embarking off to Guatemala, which did not and has not had any Value Plan or DHF funding.
While there, the discussion of Cripto Latin Fest came up, and I learned from @jthomasewsky and @starkerz that, at that time at least, "we weren't going to go" as a blockchain. Since I had been learning a lot in Guatemala about B2B HIVE onboarding, I thought this could be a good opportunity and reached out to @guiltyparties myself and mentioned that since this event was in my neck of the woods, I would be going anyway, bringing my ECOBANK team (some of whom live in Medellín) and he should get me some entrance tickets or wristbands or what turned out to be the case - "entrance NFTs".
I imagined it a bit more like when I went to LATAM in 2023, and we had no booth as HIVE but we walked around and talked to everyone in a more "B2B" type style.
But in this case, eventually Guiltyparties told me that he had reached out to @arlettemsalase and that we WOULD be having a booth as HIVE, and that I should work with Arlette. This is more similar to when I went to Cripto Latin Fest originally in 2022 in Bogotá, where we originally met and onboarded @jthomasewsky.
What about the money
So as I was arriving back home from Guatemala, I was working with Arlette about this event at the same time as I was reaching out to my team of people locally, several of which have HIVE accounts already and some for a very long time, and letting them know about the event. We didn't have a ton of time to prepare, my wife and I were physically "moving" after 6 weeks in Guatemala, and we were all behind the curve for event registration.
A few days before the event, the funds were sent out:
This format was unexpected to me, as I still had in my head that "I" was bringing my team, managing logistics as I had already begun to do since reaching out to team members and scheduling with them, getting their registration "NFTs" which were not without issue.
But further than this, I was quickly aghast to realize - @arangoaqet account was hacked.
And worse, the hack was older than 30 days. I immediately recognized this hack as one I have seen before, especially targeting people who created accounts with steemit and never changed the keys since the HIVE fork. We even made a better tool for Changing HIVE Keys because of these issues earlier this year.
After the event, we noticed that the hacker converted the HBD sent and sent the HIVE to the account @mariajruizb:
But we didn't really know anything at the time, and there was no time to think about it, the event was literally starting - we were tasked with rep'ing HIVE with a B2C focus at this event in Medellin 😑. We pooled the money of @ecoinstant and @juan.manuel and took @juan.plata with us, I put @ecoinstante's budget in savings in the meantime, as she had at this time informed me that it was just impossible for her to go represent HIVE, after having been gone for over 6 weeks, our home life, farm and family needed urgent attention.
And to be honest, even with this "hack" overhanging us, we nailed the event. We assisted Arlette, moved around the merch, grew as a team and @juan.plata even became a top onboarder - he is still eager and actively onboarding his friends here locally, he grew in his understanding and confidence about HIVE by attending the event. We supported the stand, met new people and made new connections, managed the "turn in" of the airBnB, and began the trip back home after several follow up meetings in Medellín.
Once home, we followed up with @guiltyparties, unstaked the HBD, and sent 551.25 HBD back to value plan representing @ecoinstante's budget.
As for @arangoaqet's 551.25 - its obvious something went wrong in logistics for this to have happened. I could start pointing fingers, but honestly all I do know is that logistics are hard, and in the end I did my best to with what I had, namely 3 team members were at the event, the event went well, and 1 team member's budget was returned of 4 sent.
I am happy to pay very close attention to the comments on this post, as I mentioned at the opening, if transparency is what we expect then transparency is what we must embody, and I am all for that - possibly I am slow and life has been heavy on the "transition" theme lately.
Follow up
I want to take the time this month to put my observations into a post on what I have learned about "onboarding" and "marketing" of HIVE over the course of this year. I need to shout out especially @sagarkothari88 who has done incredible and inspiring work, especially with CheckInWith.xyz - it is becoming a powerhouse onboarding tool and its progress over this year has been fantastic, and battle-tested the whole way.
There are lessons to learn - tools are being built and updated. For me at least, its time to stay home in the office for a while. And maybe write more posts.
Solid report.
Onboarding and representing Hive is a skill that grows with practice.
I would assume that if you incorporate lessons learned in your approach, each subsequent event could be more effective - subject to transient geopolitical events.
I assume across languages, regions, and cultures - there may be some different narratives that resonated more powerfully. You look like you make for an efficacious representative of Hive at these events.
Well done.
I wrote up your write up here:
https://x.com/GentlemanRural/status/1965096754723827882
Te seré muy honesta, y lo escribiré en español para que se me entienda muy bien, desde hace más de tres años estoy trabajando con la logística de este tipo de eventos y no es la primera vez que se le envía el dinero a cada usuario por separado, si revisas bien las transferencias desde mi cuenta personal y desde la cuenta de @latamwallet, te darás cuenta que no es primera vez.
Cuando se recibieron los fondos te avisé y como iba en viaje a Medellín, y para no equivocarme, te dije que una vez llegara los transfería, llegue y aún no había internet, en total demoré unas 48 horas más o menos en enviarlos desde que te avisé y tú en ningún momento me notificaste que esa cuenta estaba hackeada sino más o menos una hora luego de la transferencia.
Si buscas culpables, o quieres señalar a alguien por el "error logístico" eso claramente pasó en tu equipo y allí debes buscar el culpable, porque transferir de esta forma a cada responsable que colaborara en el evento es algo que se viene haciendo desde hace años y no habíamos presentado ningún problema hasta ese momento.
Entiendo que es TU equipo pero CADA UNO debe poder manejar sus propios fondos para su traslado, alimentación y demás actividades propias de cada uno, por eso se les transfiere de forma individual. En siguientes oportunidades, ya sabes que esta es la modalidad de trabajo (como se viene haciendo desde hace más de tres años) y no te llevaras ninguna "sorpresa" si volvemos a participar en un evento juntos.
claro que si, y haciendo aprendo. Hay pros y cons a todo, pero entiendo por que usan esta metodologia - y no he recomendado que lo cambian formalmente, pues es la diferencia entre "hacer logistica" y "recibir fondos para su traslado". Cubrimos 3 personas, volvimos 1. Hay cosas irreversibles, pero con lo que recibimos, hicimos todo posible, creo que salio bien.
Alex, se hace de esa forma para fomentar la transparencia, para que se sepa quién es el responsable de cada parte pequeña de los fondos otorgados por Value Plan y es una metodología que también le quita carga mental a quien realiza la logística principal, que en este caso fui yo, pero imagina que sea un equipo de 20 personas o más a las cuales hay que darles de comer, pagarles el bus de ida, el bus de regreso, los taxis y todo una o dos personas ¡Es mucho trabajo! Y por eso se hace esto, se les envía su dinero y se delega. Cada quien debe ser responsable de sus ingresos, al finalizar enviar las facturas y devolver lo no gastado ¡Listo!
Thank you for the report, my friend! That's quite a bugger about the account hack. I know a longtime Hiver and his wife who both recently had their accounts stolen, and via the same vector, keys unchanged since the Steem days. 😁🙏💚✨🤙