A Cascade of Education.
I’m fascinated by how trickle down can work in the real world. Not that neo-liberal mantra promoted by a kleptocratic oligarchy, but the real one. I wrote about it in my post about the Farmer’s Market, as it was the first time that I realized that the theorem itself isn’t that bad, it’s just what it’s used as an excuse for. Today I would like to discuss (please comment and complete or dismantle my arguments!) one case in reality where I can imagine that to work out on a higher level, too.
Education.
Yes, back at that little bastard, sitting in the corner of each state budget, snotty nose, dirty clothes, probably anemic and definitely malnourished, totally neglected. There’s something that always bothered me, and that I never really understood – Why are governments spending so little on education?
Assuming they don’t want us dumb.
Which of course might be the case, dumb people make great consumers and are easily manipulated, and in our egomaniac society, where everybody believes they have the right answer and everybody else is stupid and must be manipulated for their own good, well, it isn’t that far off. Generally, governments want well educated people, they even try to get them from other countries. Why not make them at home?
Too expensive.
At least in the short run. In the long run, it will pay off, and that is where the trickle-down comes in. Not only attention is like money, but education is, too. And it trickles everywhere. First, it trickles into wealth. People with a good education have a higher income, and that is not restricted to titles. A solid education on any level leads to that. That then returns in form of taxes – if the state pays for schools, it will get paid for education.
Money is not everything.
Health is important, too. And here, again, there is a direct influence of education on health. The better the education, the healthier the people are. The healthier they are, the less the state has to spend on health insurance. And that’s not all, better educated people also tend to be happier. There’s good reason that education is one of six key pathways to reach well-being.
Where does it end?
It doesn’t. Education is self-accelerating. The better educated the parents are, the better educated the children will be, if given the possibility. Currently, only the opposite is discussed, the part how being poor and having parents of lower education reduces the probability of being successful in the child’s own educational path.
Bad news make better headlines.
The narrative is always negative, even though there is a very bright side to this, as mentioned. No one has to be stuck due to being poor or having under-educated parents. In a good educational system, that would change rather quickly anyway, within one generation. As long as the parents do their part and instill values in their children that promote learning and improvement.
Poverty affects a child’s brain development, inhibiting their ability to learn and understand.
That’s from a study. It destroys my argument. Not. The same study, which is very interesting, though long, came to another quotable conclusion:
Early childhood education provides structure during cognitive and social development, which can minimize the socioeconomic achievement gap.
Again, education is a good thing. I’m not one to throw money at things to solve problems, but education is clearly an underfunded problem, and yes, the moment in time that we’re in, throwing money at it does help.
It takes endurance.
Thanks to the regression we made already, there would be a time to endure, a time of hardship. Cutting expenses elsewhere to fund education, in order to get that money back in 10-20 years. Multiplied, probably. The last study linked also mentioned a yearly loss of 700 Billion through the achievement gap and dropouts. Wasted potential, and that does not include the many children that can not develop their full potential due to lack of resources within the educational system.
The worst behaving get most support.
That’s how Tarazkp put it, and it’s true. I already tackled that issue in another post. What I did not say was that there are too few teachers for too many students. My daughter was/is one of those attention seekers, for different reasons than I pointed out, and in different ways. That was one of the reasons why I sent her to a school where the teacher has 8 children in her classroom. She can adapt to everyone’s needs accordingly, and I don’t have to worry about my daughters behavior being very negative towards others while we’re working on it. Lily does a lot better know, also thanks to that school.
Because I paid for it.
Yes, it is throwing money at the problem. And yes, it is working. There will be a point where of tipping the balance to the other side, where it will be too many resources funneled towards education which then will create a total different kind of problem. But while everything is horribly underfunded (cracks in the walls, no free food, no learning materials), that “problem” is far, far away.
Just one more thing…
Education reduces crime. You know what less crime is good for? Reducing the need for policing and according equipment. Prisons and such. Especially in the country I live in, facing a huge wave of crime in some parts of the nation, I can’t help but remember that it kind of started when the government started cutting the budget for education drastically. #ecuador had a great streak after investing a lot in education, but since that is going downwards in the last 10 years, the country seems to be in a downward spiral.
Long term thinking.
It always comes back to that. Not reacting, but acting. Setting the path for a sustainable future. The more education, the more sustainability for a society, on all levels.
What do you think? Could education be the salvation? Where are the pitfalls?
Great post. One of the things that struck me the last time I went for an eye test (my vision is fine, don't worry!) - I was talking to the optometrist, and she did a lot of work with the prison system. She had written a paper along with a criminologist that most people in prison where there because they didn't have eye sight that was checked and corrected with glasses.
The lack of glasses was a root cause to a poor outcome during their education. Many had never had their eyes checked. That lack of education was a root cause of the events leading to imprisonment. Not just education about stuff, but education about what they didn't know that they needed - glasses.
It was an EYE OPENING (pun) perspective on how such a small thing that so many take for granted can set people down a path of despair.
It's definitely a factor, as children in low-income families also have restricted access to health prevention and remedies like glasses, plus stigmatization. For an optometrist (glad your eyes are fine!), the root of all evil may lie in the eyes (which do have a lot of impact on our lives, more than many people think), but the deeper cause is probably still poverty.
We had our eyes tested at our school. Here in Ecuador, the eye test was mandatory before going to school. So it seems to have made some waves.
Yes, absolutely, the root cause is still poverty!
On eye tests before school - That is a very interesting thing to do - should be the same for driving licences :D
Yes, that would be a great addition! :-P
How people are driving here is a totally different question. There, too, one notices the lack if education. And consideration. There's so much going wrong, and starting with education seems to be the best beginning for solving everything. Even dark matter.
Education is always the salvation. There's a lot of negativity around education systems as they currently stand, but of course education empowers. There's so much research into how education can give people autonomy over their lives, more choices, more resources, more means to make a better life for themselves.
Having spent years as an educator myself, this is often the issue - having a negative view of teachers and schools, and not making a distinction between then and now, or teaching the child to be curious and value education despite the things they may not like about it - has such a big influence on students. I have so little respect for hte parents who come in and say in front of their child: 'oh I hated school' or 'you'll never need to know that in real life' or 'no wonder you're bad at that, I never was' - set such poor examples for their child and limit their ability to get ahead through education. Of course, no one has to have a university education, but a solid foundation provides such benefits to life and can't be ignored.
Even if it's the ability to dissassemble the bullshit we're fed via governments and media. To think critically.
Here in Australia people look down on Aboriginal people as if they're not good enough and that they could have been more successful if they'd just tried. They don't begin to understand that education hasn't been top of the list for people who've had so many human rights removed from them in the last 200 years, and that this kind of wealth - like health - is inherited. They will argue that they get more 'handouts' than 'white' Australia without rationalising that they've had proportionately less over time, and that funding education is attempting to redress the balance, to give people back their autonomy. I'm sure it's similiar in all kinds of countries with all kinds of people. This is just one example.
And yes, we can be cynical too and look at what areas of education are defunded. For example, the removal of funding for the arts and students having to foot the bill for an Arts degree when science students are subsidised. Of course, Arts students are more likely to critique those in power.
I could go on and am probably rambling. It's a day for it - raining here. I'm glad your daughter is in a school where she gets the focus and attention she deserves. There was nothing that made me more irate than a pedagogical 'guru' who said class size didn't matter - of course it does. Even if it matters only to the teacher marking the essays and preparing the work and feeding the passions of their charges - this has a trickle down affect too!
Great article.
Wow, thank you for that long comment! Always love it when people take the time to give an extended opinion - it's mostly not rambling to me.
The empowering part is very important, but as many second-layer effects of education overlooked way too many times. The second or third generation of educated members of a family might see it, but the first usually doesn't. It's the promise of a better job and money that brings people into what they think is education, but is just a paper mill, at least here. You need a university title to be worth something. It doesn't matter if you're actually skilled for that, or if your talents lie in a trade craft, everyone wants to go to university just because.
Also, trade crafts don't have schools here, most of them at least. You learn by doing, taught my someone who learned the same way. But it's mostly bad quality. The stories I could tell... A trade craft school would be amazing here, though without any teachers.
The inheritance part is important, the interviews I listened to are an example of that. The family is so incredibly important on all fronts, but since we're in a downwards spiral of values at the moment, it's getting harder and harder to reverse that. Just motivational speeches won't do the trick, hence throwing money at the problem just might.
The funding is how the system wants people to be. Arts and cultural studies don't have much direct economic impact, they "just" educate people and make them have nasty emotions and thoughts.
@topcomment please curate the comment above, if you find it as well written as I!
In Australia we used to have tech schools, which were focused on things like woodwork, metalwork etc that led to trades. Unfortunately they shut those down in favour of putting everyone on same path. But education isn't cookie cutter.
People do need motivated, knowledgeable and passionate teachers teachers to motivate them to step into lifelong journeys of curiosity and self improvement and sadly, yep, you need money for that.
You've gained a new follower with this post.
My grandfather always told me to learn a trade first, and then study, though I was quite good in regular schooling. My plan was to become a carpenter and then travel South America working. I'm glad I didn't, there's little regard for crafts or quality here, and even less payment. I might've starved :-D
The cookie cutter is a good example. There's little regard for any talents at all. That's why I'm so happy with Lily's Waldorf school. They're a little over the top from time to time, giving the kids a little too much space and not enough structure, but that's minor in comparison to what regular school is like here.
And you gained a follower, too, after checking out your blog. Looking forward to reading more!
What a shame there's no regard for crafts. I guess everything has to mature. I know there's a big resurgence in the valuing of good craft here - I mean anyone in the building trade earns more than teachers but building or making custom, bespoke furniture or beautiful hand crafted things does alright too. The 'slow' movement has a market!
It's a market of contemplation that has real value. Though most people might just want to show it off. And yes, I'm cynical about that all. But I love to pay for good work. I have one carpenter who's quite the genius. Around 20% more expensive than others, but he gets the right wood, the right quality, and me. He gets me. Which is hard. And he always comes back to make sure everything is perfect, and even the smallest thing that wasn't quite perfect - he'll be on my doorstep the next day to fix it.
It's a thing of community as well. One has to get to know those who are eligible for community, and those who aren't. He'd be my community carpenter. I know who to call for solid structure work. Who for arts. Who for white line. Who for the garden. But that takes time, to build that community. Many people move around too quickly, or never overcome the fragmentation that comes with the superficiality these days. Dang. I forgot to put the dill seeds in the ground.
Community means so much. Here there's a lot of young 'tradies' as we call them starting businesses and trying to male their way. They're better than the old guard - more polite, more willing, more keen. Happy to support them... EXCEPT every time we get a quote my husband ends up doing it himself 🤣
I've never been a fan of dill, and apart from potatoes or salmon, I'm not sure how to use it. It's the single herb I have no affinity with!
Well, potato and fish is about it. Cucumbers and pickles are in there, too, but besides that... I make a lot of dill pickles, so I always need a good amount. They're in the earth now, let's see if they sprout!
Okay I can definitely live with dill pickles! My Nana was German, so it's a little bit in my DNA... :P
Your reply is upvoted by @topcomment; a manual curation service that rewards meaningful and engaging comments.
More Info - Support us! - Reports - Discord Channel
Would you like to support our community?
You can delegate a little HP to this account; every little bit helps make this constellation shine brighter.
You can join the discord server to share cosmic moments and participate in intergalactic activities.
Join our healing trail, be part of the galactic journey where together we shine brighter.
Thank you!
!PAKX
View or trade
PAKX
tokens.Use !PAKX command if you hold enough balance to call for a @pakx vote on worthy posts! More details available on PAKX Blog.
It is true that money buys everything, but if it can give you peace of mind, that peace of mind of not having to worry if we make it to the end of the month, when you get sick, being able to buy the medicines you need, in a certain way it gives us peace of mind.
It does. I'm not against money, I just don't think it solves every problem. But with education at its current state - yes, the primary factor is the lack of funding.
I like reading about how education can make things better for everyone. The part about how it can help stop crime and make the world more sustainable is really important.
It is indeed! The multiple layers of positive impact are more impressive the deeper you dig into it.
Congratulations @beelzael! You have completed the following achievement on the Hive blockchain And have been rewarded with New badge(s)
Your next target is to reach 2500 replies.
You can view your badges on your board and compare yourself to others in the Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word
STOP
Education is like planting seeds, you need patience, but the payoff is huge. Wish more people saw that.
The seed in this case is a lot of money. A change of balancing values. Getting away from individualism and back to community.